Search Is a Team Sport: Lessons From BrightonSEO San Diego 2026

Search has always been a team sport. SEO has depended on developers, writers, PR teams, designers, subject-matter experts, and others for as long as I have been doing it. What has changed is the number of players on the field and the number of places where their work can influence whether a brand gets found, understood, and chosen. That was the idea I kept returning to as I reviewed my notes from BrightonSEO San Diego 2026.

On my way to the plane after an unexpectedly thorough trip through airport security. As someone who already struggles with flying, this was exactly the calming start I needed.

Getting to San Diego from Boston was also a bit of a personal accomplishment for me. I have struggled with flying for years, and it has sometimes affected the trips I have been willing to take. Flying across the country for BrightonSEO pushed me well outside my comfort zone, but this was a conference I really wanted to attend. I am glad I made the trip. A big thank you to my friend Beth Nunnington at Journey Further for helping to make this happen.

Over two days at the San Diego Convention Center, I attended a wide variety of sessions covering SEO strategy, AI search, digital PR, social media, video, local search, brand authority, technical SEO, measurement, and more. It was also my third major SEO conference this year after attending SMX in Boston and MozCon in New York. As I went through my notes afterward, I started seeing connections between presentations that, on the surface, you might think were about very different areas of marketing.

Speakers discussing YouTube were talking about search demand. Digital PR presentations were talking about AI citations and brand understanding. Local search research followed consumers from search to AI to social to reviews. Technical SEO presentations focused on whether AI systems could retrieve and understand website content. Sessions about reviews showed how customer language could inform content and search strategy. Individually, these were presentations about different specialties. Taken together, they described a search ecosystem that increasingly depends on those specialties working together.

Inside the exhibition hall at BrightonSEO San Diego 2026, where attendees could meet vendors, catch up with others in the industry, and continue conversations between sessions.

Jen Cornwell gave me a good way to think about all of this during the first session of the conference when she said, “Search is a behavior, not a channel.” Where people search, how they search, what influences the next search, and how they make decisions have all expanded. Organic discovery can now be influenced by social, product, PR, commerce, web development, paid search, content, creative, video, and SEO. This means that no single team owns all of those areas. Together they influence whether a brand gets discovered and, what matters most, chosen.

Search has always been a team sport. One of my biggest takeaways from BrightonSEO was just how many more players are now on the field and how much more connected their roles have become.

Search Is Already Cross-Functional

Jen Cornwell at BrightonSEO San Diego, where she argued that “search is a behavior, not a channel,” an idea that became one of my biggest takeaways from the conference.

Jen’s presentation, Why Your 2026 SEO Strategy Must Be a Cross-Functional OS, provided several practical examples of what that can look like. For YouTube, creators, and AI search, her collaboration framework included planning for clarity rather than focusing on keywords and engagement, reviewing the formats and creators already being cited within a category, selecting creators based on category language and readiness, and tracking sentiment themes and brand narratives. The supporting work included shared topic-cluster briefs, citation reviews by platform and theme, creator shortlists, and sentiment findings that could feed the next creator brief.

Those activities don’t usually fit inside one traditional SEO box. Search data can help creators understand the language people use. Video teams understand what works with their audiences. Social teams see conversations and sentiment developing in real time. PR understands publishers and narratives. SEO can study which sources, formats, entities, and topics are appearing across search and AI results. The opportunity comes from putting all of that information together.

Jen also spent time on the harder organizational question of how do you actually make that happen. Her framework for building change started with creating urgency, building a coalition, forming a vision, and getting people involved before moving into removing barriers, generating wins, sustaining momentum, and eventually making the new process part of how the organization works. Cross-functional SEO sounds straightforward when presented as a strategy. It becomes much harder when it requires resources and cooperation from people with different priorities.

Ruth Burr Reedy followed Jen with a presentation that addressed that problem from another direction. She pointed out that SEOs tend to care about traffic, visibility, share of voice, engagement, links, and similar metrics, while organizations ultimately care about leads, sales, revenue, retention, and lifetime value. Her line that “your metrics are your problem” was a useful reminder that getting another team to care about an SEO objective requires connecting that objective to something they care about.

Ruth Burr Reedy’s five ways SEOs can keep momentum: connect inputs to outputs, build relationships, speak their language, respect people’s time, and report and refine.

Ruth’s five recommendations for maintaining momentum were to connect inputs to outputs, build relationships, speak their language, respect people’s time, and report and refine. Taken together, Jen and Ruth offered a useful foundation for much of what followed during the conference. Search depends on work happening throughout an organization, while making that work requires relationships and an exchange of useful information between teams.

Discovery Doesn’t Stay in One Channel

The social and video sessions made Jen’s point especially clear because the relationship between search and social now runs in both directions.

Shadae McCallum presenting “The TikTok Hustle: Why Your Viral Video Is Lying to You” at BrightonSEO San Diego, with a focus on creating for people rather than algorithms.

Shadae McCallum began with a reminder that can get lost when we talk about algorithms: “Views are living people.” She compared 100 views to filling an auditorium with 100 people who chose to give you some of their time. Her recommendations included defining the conversion, connecting social output to business goals, using two-way calls to action, benchmarking against comparable accounts, participating consistently in communities, and using TikTok’s Creator Search Insights to identify active search demand.

That last recommendation is a good example of the boundaries between channels becoming increasingly arbitrary. Search behavior can inform social content, while the resulting social activity can create additional interest and demand.

Cindy Krum approached the relationship from the other direction. One of her slides described modern Google journeys as “Searching / Streaming / Social / Scrolling / Shopping = Searching.” Her presentation focused heavily on video and AI Overviews, but the overarching point she made was that discovery can begin well before the search that eventually appears in an SEO report.

Cindy recommended researching videos already ranking in AI Overviews, studying query fan-out results, mapping those findings to a brand or its products, and considering whether a video might be a better answer than another blog post. Her sample workflow moved from creating a video or podcast through publishing across platforms, optimizing YouTube, cutting longer videos into shorter formats, promoting them through email, social and communities, connecting social profiles, and ultimately targeting visibility within AI Overviews.

One of her final points described video as having a “deeper power to drive search volume through upstream visibility.” I think that is an important way to look at the relationship between social and SEO. Some of the search demand we eventually measure may have originated with a creator, video, podcast, social post, streaming experience, or conversation somewhere else.

Cindy Krum, Shadae McCallum, and Will Robinson during a Q&A on social media, video, and search at BrightonSEO San Diego 2026.

Will Robinson’s research added another layer. His team tested 17 video traits across four AI models, including channel size, subscribers, views, likes, comments, video length, upload cadence and several other familiar YouTube signals. Most showed no reliable effect across all four models. His research also found that rewording a question could change which videos were cited, leading to his recommendation to “aim for the topic, not the prompt.”

Will’s practical recommendations were to cover the topic rather than optimize for individual prompts, put the topic in the title and description, continue publishing fresh content, and spread efforts across channels. This is another reason I am skeptical of treating AI search as a collection of individual prompts that can each be optimized like keywords. The broader topic, the content available around it, and where that content exists I believe matter more.

Will Robinson presenting at BrightonSEO San Diego on his research into which video signals influence citations across AI search platforms.

Brooke Weller showed that this extends beyond video. Her research into LinkedIn content found that many highly cited articles shared characteristics we would recognize from good web content: clear headings, lists, named entities, data, and formats such as comparisons, educational explainers, and “how to choose” guides. Her advice was essentially to structure LinkedIn content like webpages while keeping it fresh and accessible to LLMs.

These presentations were ostensibly about social media, video, LinkedIn, YouTube, and AI search. Together, they described a much larger search discovery system in which demand and information move back and forth between platforms.

Authority Is Being Built Across the Web

The digital PR sessions extended the same idea into authority and brand understanding. Noah Greenberg argued that showing up across the web is likely to remain important even as individual platforms and tactics change. One of his recommendations for widening distribution was to collaborate with Content and Communications teams to identify content strong enough to distribute, match that content to what relevant publishers are already picking up, and measure citation lift against a baseline.

Eric Hoover took the idea further. His three takeaways were that messaging across search and media platforms is becoming a new “source of truth,” that mentions and citations fluctuate and therefore require consistency between owned and cited information, and that teaming up owned and earned media helps brands become found, understood, and chosen.

AI systems are gathering information about companies from both the sources companies control and those they do not. A website may present a company one way, while publishers, reviews, creators, social conversations, and other external sources can reinforce that understanding or create a very different picture of the brand.

Amanda Walls approached this through authority gaps. Her analysis went beyond looking at which competitors had links that you did not. She recommended studying competitor topics, publication frequency, external visibility, and topical, journalist, and editorial gaps. Authority in that framework becomes a question of what subjects and associations a brand has established across the wider information environment.

Jake Gauntley tied many of those ideas together with what he called a “Consistent Content Ecosystem.” His process began with search-first insight and customer pain points, moved into pillar and cluster content on the website, and then extended outward through creators, YouTube, communities, TikTok, data reports, statistics, thought leadership, and product roundups. His formula, “consistent signals × corroboration = confidence,” captures why those activities become more powerful when they reinforce one another.

Jake Gauntley’s “Consistent Content Ecosystem,” connecting search insights and customer pain points with onsite content, creators, social, communities, YouTube, and digital PR.

I particularly liked Jake’s approach to pain-point research because it demonstrated how information can flow back into search strategy. He recommended mining problem topics across platforms, analyzing reviews for emotional pain points, and then verifying those findings through social, community, and search examples. Reviews, Reddit discussions, social conversations, search behavior, and other customer signals become inputs to the content strategy rather than separate datasets owned by separate teams.F

None of this means traditional SEO signals have stopped mattering. Michael Johnson presented research showing a continuing correlation between backlinks, referring domains, and Google rankings. He also recommended monitoring unlinked brand mentions for opportunities to earn links back to relevant pages. A PR placement or brand mention can therefore contribute to awareness, external corroboration, AI visibility, entity associations, and traditional link authority at the same time.

The lines between SEO, PR, content, social, and brand have never been perfectly clean, but they become even less useful when the same activity can contribute to several of them at once.

Customers Don’t Respect Your Org Chart

The strongest evidence for the cross-channel nature of search came from research into what customers actually do.

Damian Rollison presented SOCi’s 2026 Local Discovery Index and introduced what he called the “Verification Loop.” He described it as the nonlinear path consumers take when choosing a local business, where something discovered on one channel is cross-checked against information found elsewhere. This replaces the basic funnel from awareness to purchase with a loop between discovery, verification, and action.

Damian Rollison’s five takeaways from the SOCi 2026 Local Discovery Index, showing how consumers move across search, AI, social, and reviews as they discover, verify, and choose local businesses.

In the research Damian presented, 83% of respondents had used search engines for local discovery in the previous 30 days, while 55% used social media and 52% used AI tools. Once consumers moved into verification, 99% read online reviews, 40% previewed the business on social media, and 38% checked its menu or offerings. At the action stage, 72% preferred businesses that respond to reviews, 59% said they became a customer because of social content, and 62% had chosen another business because information was missing.

The mix also changed depending on the industry. Traditional search remained the largest starting point across the categories Damian showed, but AI-first journeys were more common in healthcare and grocery, social over-indexed in financial services, and Maps played a larger role in fuel and automotive searches. Different factors also influenced the final decision depending on the category.

This is why the customer journey matters more than the org chart. A customer may encounter a business in an AI answer, search the company on Google, read reviews, visit the website, look at social content, watch a video, and eventually return through a branded search or direct visit. Internally, we may assign those interactions to AI visibility, SEO, reputation management, web, social, video, and brand. The customer experiences one business.

Beth Nunnington presenting at BrightonSEO San Diego on how brands need to be found, understood, and ultimately chosen across search and AI.

Beth Nunnington offered another framework for understanding that journey: Found → Understood → Chosen. She described technical, content, and brand trust signals as three pillars of organic growth and discovery and emphasized the role of third-party proof. In research she presented, 93% of the AI Search citations in the dataset came from third-party sources or earned media.

Her framework begins with understanding where the audience gets information and what topics, publishers, formats, and emotional triggers resonate with them. Being understood requires consistent messaging across owned, earned, and paid content so that humans and machines form an accurate picture of the brand. Being chosen then requires the trust signals that support a decision.

Celeste Gonzalez approached trust through reviews. Her framing was that “Every search is a trust decision in disguise.” Rather than treating reviews only as a reputation-management task, she recommended using review text as customer research. Recurring positive and negative themes, operational failures, emotional pain points, customer language, and gaps between praise and complaints can all be extracted from reviews, including competitor reviews.

Celeste Gonzalez presenting at BrightonSEO San Diego on how reviews can reveal customer language, pain points, and trust gaps that can inform SEO and content strategy.

That information can help far more than the person responsible for responding to reviews. Content teams can learn how customers describe their problems. SEO can identify terminology and topics. Sales can better understand objections. Operations can identify recurring service issues. Social teams can find subjects that generate strong reactions. PR can compare the story a company wants to tell with what customers actually experience.

The information should move between teams because the customer already does.

Your Website Still Connects Much of the System

With so much attention on off-site discovery, social platforms, AI answers, reviews, and earned media, it would be easy to start to think that the website isn’t important anymore. Several technical presentations made the opposite case.

Matt Thompson discussed building websites for both people and agents. His AI-friendly delivery checklist included semantic, well-organized HTML, less navigation clutter, text alternatives for rich media, server-side rendering of important content, alignment between schema and visible page content, and pages that are dense and self-sufficient.

Matt Thompson’s AI-friendly delivery checklist, outlining how websites can make content easier for AI systems to access, understand, and cite.

Sam Torres showed what can happen when those fundamentals are ignored. One of her slides summarized the problem as “If your content needs JavaScript to appear, AI search doesn’t know it exists.” She qualified that with some exceptions, but her larger point was that crawling, rendering, and indexing are different processes and that businesses should actually test what machines receive.

Her auditing process included looking at the raw response, disabling JavaScript to see what disappears, checking what is actually indexed, and examining server logs to understand what bots are doing. That requires SEO and development to work together. A content team can create an excellent resource, but its value to search and AI systems changes dramatically if the implementation makes important information difficult to retrieve.

Martha van Berkel’s framework for turning the website into a semantic data layer that helps search engines and AI systems better understand a brand and its content.

Martha van Berkel extended the idea from accessibility to understanding. She described the website as becoming a “Semantic Data Layer for Marketing.” Her framework starts by creating a foundation for machine understanding, builds topic authority on top of it, and eventually makes that structured understanding available to a broader AI and agent ecosystem.

That requires more than adding schema markup. The company needs to know what its entities are, maintain accurate information about them, connect internal business context with external authoritative sources, and govern that information over time. SEO, content, development, product, and other business stakeholders may all have pieces of the information required to make that work.

So, the website remains an important part of the system. Its role is expanding from a collection of pages designed to rank into a structured source of information that people, search engines, AI systems, and now agents can use.

Measurement Has to Reflect the Journey

Cross-channel discovery also creates a measurement problem. Jill Maldonado provided one of the more useful ways of thinking about it.

Her starting point was that marketers already spend money on activities that influence outcomes without providing a clean line in a dashboard. A rebrand, TV advertising, direct mail, event sponsorship, or word of mouth can affect what people eventually search for and buy even when the attribution system cannot neatly assign credit. AI search fits into that larger problem.

Jill divided measurement into a leading visibility layer and a lagging outcomes layer. The visibility layer includes citations, mentions, and share of voice, but she emphasized that credible measurement starts with the decisions behind those numbers: which topics you want to own, which prompts you track, which competitors you compare against, and which platforms you include.

The outcomes layer looks at measures we already have, including branded search, AI-channel traffic where it can be identified, direct traffic, and site conversion rate. Her recommendation was: “Report the layers side by side. Never blend them.”

Jill Maldonado’s measurement framework for reporting leading AI visibility metrics alongside lagging business outcomes without blending the two.

I like that approach because it avoids pretending we can attribute every conversion to one interaction. A customer might watch a video, encounter an article through digital PR, ask ChatGPT about the category, search the brand on Google, read reviews, and eventually convert through a direct visit. The final source recorded in analytics tells us very little about everything that influenced the decision.

The same idea applies beyond AI measurement. Search teams should understand how their work connects to business outcomes without pretending that a dashboard can perfectly reconstruct every customer’s journey.

SEO Can Become the Connector

None of this means SEO should own social media, PR, video, development, sales, reviews, or every other function that can influence discovery. That would replace one silo with an even larger one that in most cases would be unmanageable. The opportunity I see here is for SEO to become more of a connector, or like a conductor in an orchestra.

Search teams already spend a lot of time studying what people ask, how they describe problems, which topics are related, which competitors appear, which sources search engines trust, what content gets retrieved, how websites are interpreted by machines, and what information appears throughout a search journey. That information can help other teams make better decisions.

At the same time, those teams have information SEO needs. Sales conversations contain the questions prospects actually ask. Reviews contain customer language, expectations, and frustrations. Social and community teams see conversations developing before they necessarily appear in keyword tools. PR teams understand publishers, narratives, and third-party validation. Paid search teams know which messages and landing pages convert. Developers understand what machines can actually retrieve from the website.

Andy Crestodina delivering the closing keynote at BrightonSEO San Diego on AI recommendations, buyer journeys, and creating content that helps brands become the chosen answer.

Andy Crestodina provided a good example during the closing keynote when he recommended using actual sales conversations to identify prospect questions rather than relying on generic third-party FAQ sources. His broader advice was to use AI to identify deficiencies rather than simply efficiencies. A transcript from a sales call can reveal a question that should be answered on a service page, in a video, through sales material, in social content, or across several of those places.

Patrick Stox describing technical SEOs as “the janitors of the internet,” reflecting the often unseen work required to keep websites accessible, functional, and understandable to search engines.

Patrick Stox made a related point about the role of people as AI tools become more widely available. One of his slides said, “In a world where everyone has the same automated tools, the winner will be the one with the best Human Strategist.” Automation can help collect information, analyze it, create drafts, monitor visibility, and handle repetitive work. Someone still has to decide what matters, understand the customer, connect the information, and determine what should happen next.

The connections also continue after discovery. Jeremy Burgos focused on what happens when someone actually becomes a lead, including reducing friction and responding quickly. Search, social, PR, reviews, content, video, and AI visibility can all contribute to creating an opportunity, but the value of that work can disappear quickly if the business fails to respond or creates friction once the customer tries to engage.

That brings us back to Ruth’s advice to connect inputs to outputs. Rankings, citations, impressions, mentions, links, views, and traffic all have value as diagnostic and performance measures. Businesses ultimately need those activities to contribute to leads, customers, revenue, retention, or whatever outcome they are trying to create.

Search Is a Team Sport

SEO did not suddenly become cross-functional in 2026. It has always depended on people and work outside the SEO team. What stood out to me at BrightonSEO was how much the ecosystem around search has expanded. Search still matters. Websites still matter. Technical SEO still matters. Content and backlinks still matter. What has changed is the number of places where discovery can happen, the number of signals that can influence what someone finds, and how closely those different parts of the customer journey now interact.

A social conversation can identify a customer problem that becomes a piece of content. That content can become a video. The video can create search demand and later become a source in an AI answer. PR can put the same expertise in front of publishers, creating mentions, links, citations, and external validation. Reviews can reinforce or undermine the claims being made everywhere else. The website can organize those ideas and entities into information that machines can retrieve and understand. Sales conversations can then reveal what the entire system still fails to answer.

The teams responsible for those activities may remain separate. Their information increasingly cannot.

Jen Cornwell’s line from the beginning of the conference is the one I keep returning to: “Search is a behavior, not a channel.” If that is how people search, our strategies need to reflect it.